She Already Bought Plane Tickets to Visit Her Parents for Thanksgiving, and Now Her Manager Wants Her to Argue With a Coworker Over Who Has to Cancel Their Approved Time Off
A woman requested three days off around Thanksgiving back in August, got approval, and booked flights to visit her parents. Another coworker requested two of the same days and was approved too, but neither of them knew.
After a teammate quit unexpectedly, their manager decided they couldn’t both be off. Instead of making the call himself, he brought the two of them into a meeting and asked them to decide whose vacation was more important.
Billing Team of Six
She works on a six-person team handling billing and account issues at a midsize company. The team works closely and depends on each other to keep things running smoothly.
She’s worked with the coworker involved for almost three years. They’ve always gotten along well.
That’s part of why the situation feels so frustrating. A scheduling issue suddenly put strain on a good working relationship.
Thanksgiving Time Off Approved in August
In August, she requested three days off around Thanksgiving. Her plan was to visit her parents.
Her manager approved the request. With that approval, she booked flights and made her plans.
Holiday travel can be expensive. Airfare around Thanksgiving often costs more than usual, and changing or canceling flights can bring fees or lost money.
Overlapping Requests Nobody Caught
Another coworker had also requested two of those same days off. Her request was approved too.
Neither employee knew about the other’s plans. Their manager is the one who reviews and approves time off.
Both followed the company’s process. They asked early and received approval months in advance.
Sudden Resignation and a Coverage Gap
Last week, a teammate resigned unexpectedly. That left the team short-staffed.
Her manager decided both employees couldn’t be away at the same time. Someone would need to stay to cover the work.
She understands the staffing problem. What surprised her was how her manager chose to handle it.
Meeting to Work It Out Themselves
Her manager scheduled a meeting with just the two employees. She expected him to explain a coverage plan.
Instead, he said he wanted to give them a chance to work it out between themselves. He was asking them to decide who would give up their approved time off.
That put both employees in an uncomfortable position. Neither wanted to be the one to cancel.
Plane Tickets Versus Childcare
She explained that she’d already bought plane tickets. Canceling could mean losing money or paying change fees.
Her coworker said she’d arranged childcare and had family traveling from out of state. Her plans also involved time and money.
Then their manager asked them to explain whose trip was more important. Suddenly, they were comparing their personal lives.
Comment About Not Having Kids
Her coworker talked about how rarely she gets to see her family. She felt pressure to defend her own plans so she wouldn’t automatically lose.
At one point, her coworker said that at least she didn’t have kids to work around. The comment hurt.
She knows her coworker was frustrated, but it still felt personal. The conversation turned into a contest neither of them wanted.
Friday Deadline and a Strained Coworker Bond
The meeting ended without a decision. Their manager gave them until Friday to figure it out because he didn’t want to be the bad guy.
Afterward, her coworker barely spoke to her. She doesn’t want to damage their relationship or cancel a trip she’s already paid for, and she’s left wondering how to push back on her manager without turning a staffing problem into a fight with a coworker she genuinely likes.
Featured on Happy From Home:
- Woman Who Put Down $100,000 on Her House Before Her Boyfriend Moved In Says He Has Started Calling It a Waste of Money Because He Has No Legal Claim to It After Two Years of Contributions
- Father Who Searched for a Missing 4-Year-Old While Managing His Own Two Young Children Says the Boy’s Dad Who Was Home Watching TV Is Now Demanding an Apology From Him for Not Watching Closely Enough
