Woman angry while sending an email on her phone

She’s Selling Her Couch Set for $800 After Her Brother-in-Law Gave It Away Without Asking, and Now She’s Afraid Posting the Listing in the Family Chat Will Start a Fight

A woman got a text from her brother-in-law’s girlfriend asking when she could swing by to pick up the couch and coffee table. The woman had no idea what she was talking about.

It turned out her brother-in-law had read a passing comment in the family group chat about redecorating and told his girlfriend, and his mom, that the furniture was up for grabs. Now the woman has listed the set for $800 and is thinking about dropping that listing right back into the family chat.

Unexpected Text About Her Couch

The message came out of nowhere. Her brother-in-law’s girlfriend wanted to set up a time to collect the furniture.

She’d even measured her apartment and started planning where everything would go. From her point of view, it was already settled.

The woman doesn’t blame her. The girlfriend was polite and clearly believed she’d been given the set fair and square.

Furniture She Never Offered

The couch and coffee table have been in the woman’s living room for about three years. She bought both pieces herself, before she and her husband were married.

They’ve held up well and still look great. She’s simply ready for a new look in the room.

At no point did she say she was getting rid of them. As far as she knew, the set was still hers to decide what to do with.

Her Actual Message in the Chat

A few days earlier, she’d mentioned in the family group chat that she was thinking about redoing the living room. She added that she’d been browsing for new furniture.

That was it. There was no offer, no giveaway, and no mention of the old pieces at all.

To her, it was the kind of small life update families share all the time. She never imagined it would be read as a promise.

Brother-in-Law’s Assumption

When she called her brother-in-law, he said she’d talked about buying new furniture, so he figured she didn’t want the old set. He didn’t see why she was making a big deal of it.

He had passed that assumption along as fact. His girlfriend thought the set was hers, and so did his mom.

His mom even texted the woman separately, saying how sweet it was that she was passing the furniture on to someone who could use it. By then, the story had spread faster than the woman could correct it.

Resale Value of a Well-Kept Set

Good furniture that’s been cared for can keep a lot of its value. A couch and coffee table in great condition can often sell for hundreds of dollars.

She listed the set on an online marketplace for $800. Within a day, two buyers had already messaged her.

That money is part of her plan. Redoing a living room can easily cost $1,500 to $3,000 or more, so selling the old pieces helps cover the new ones.

Money She Was Counting On

Giving the set away would mean losing that $800. She’d have to cover more of the new furniture out of her own pocket.

She isn’t willing to do that just because her brother-in-law made a promise on her behalf. It wasn’t his furniture to give.

To her, the issue isn’t the girlfriend. It’s that someone else decided what happened to something she paid for.

Husband Who Wants to Let It Go

Her husband thinks she should just hand over the furniture. He doesn’t want a fight and says his brother didn’t mean any harm.

She understands he wants to keep the peace. But she feels letting it slide would mean accepting that her things can be promised away without asking.

She also worries it could happen again. If it works this time, she wonders what her brother-in-law might offer up next.

One Reply in the Group Chat

What she wants to do is reply to her original message in the family chat with the listing and the price. That way, everyone sees the set is for sale, not free.

If the girlfriend still wants it, she’s welcome to buy it for $800 like anyone else. The woman is left weighing whether that reply would quietly set the record straight or whether it would turn an awkward misunderstanding into a bigger family fight.

Featured on Happy From Home:

Similar Posts