Two women arguing and looking upset

She Lent Her Expensive Formal Dress to a Friend Who Promised to Be Careful, and It Came Back Stained, and Now the Friend Says She’s Being Unreasonable for Asking Her to Cover the Cleaning

A 21-year-old woman bought an expensive dress for a formal university event, hoping it would be something she could wear again. A friend asked to borrow it for a dinner the following weekend.

She hesitated because this friend had returned borrowed clothes in worse shape before, but the friend promised to be extra careful. The dress came back with a stain the dry cleaner can’t guarantee they can remove, and when she asked her friend to at least cover the cleaning, the friend said she was being unreasonable.

Formal University Event

Last month, she attended a formal event at her university. She wanted to look her best.

Events like that often require dressier outfits than students usually own. Buying formal clothes can be a big expense, especially on a student budget.

She planned carefully for the night. The dress was an important part of that.

Expensive Dress Meant to Be Worn Again

She bought a dress specifically for the event. It was more expensive than her usual clothes.

She chose it because she wanted something she could wear again. That way, the cost would feel more worthwhile.

Formal dresses can easily cost $100 to $300 or more. For a college student, that’s a significant purchase.

Friend Asks to Borrow It

A week later, a friend asked if she could borrow the dress. She had a dinner coming up and wanted something nice to wear.

The woman wasn’t sure at first. The dress was important to her.

Still, she wanted to be a good friend. Sharing clothes is common among friends, especially for special events.

Past Clothes Returned Worse for Wear

She hesitated because this same friend had borrowed clothes before. Those items had come back in a different condition.

That made her nervous about lending something more expensive. She worried the same thing might happen again.

Her friend promised she’d be extra careful this time. Trusting that promise, the woman agreed.

Stain Near the Hem

When the dress was returned, there was a noticeable stain near the bottom. Her friend said she’d accidentally spilled something on it.

She also said she’d already tried washing it. Unfortunately, that didn’t remove the stain.

Seeing the dress damaged was frustrating. It was the outcome she’d been worried about from the start.

Special Finish and an Uncertain Fix

The fabric has a special finish, which made the stain harder to treat. The woman took it to a dry cleaner.

The cleaner said they couldn’t guarantee they’d be able to remove the stain. Specialty cleaning can often cost $20 to $60 or more, depending on the fabric and damage.

If the stain can’t be removed, she may not be able to wear the dress again. That would mean losing the full value of what she paid.

Offering a Two-Part Payment

She asked her friend to at least cover the cleaning cost. She wasn’t asking for the full price of the dress.

Her friend said she didn’t have that kind of money. The woman offered to let her pay in two parts to make it easier.

She thought that was a fair compromise. It would spread the cost out while still taking responsibility for the damage.

Accidents Happen, She Said

Her friend said she was being unreasonable. She pointed out that accidents happen and that she’d already apologized.

The woman feels differently. Her friend knew the dress was expensive and bought for a special occasion, and she’s left wondering whether asking for help with the cleaning is fair or whether she should simply accept the loss to keep the friendship intact.


Featured on Happy From Home:

Similar Posts