Young man talking on the phone looking angry

She Gave Her Brother Ice and Paper Plates for Thanksgiving After Years of Him Not Bringing Anything, and Now She’s Deciding Whether to Cover for Him in Front of His New Girlfriend

A woman’s family holds Thanksgiving at her mom’s house every year, using a sign-up sheet in the group chat so everyone brings something different. This year, it was her turn to run it, and she assigned her brother ice and paper plates.

For the past few years, her brother signed up for a real dish and showed up with a bag of gas station ice instead. Now his girlfriend is coming for the first time, he’s told her it’s a family joke, and he wants his sister to change the sheet and tell everyone to drop it.

Thanksgiving Sign-Up Sheet Rotation

The family uses a shared sign-up sheet to plan the meal. It helps avoid ending up with three mac and cheese dishes and no vegetables.

Family members take turns organizing it each year. This year, the job fell to her.

Thanksgiving potlucks can help spread out the cost. Instead of one person paying for everything, each guest contributes part of the meal.

Three Years of Gas Station Ice

In past years, her brother signed up to bring an actual dish. Each time, he arrived with a bag of ice from a gas station instead.

He said he ran out of time. The family adjusted, but it left gaps in the meal.

When someone doesn’t bring their assigned dish, others often end up covering it. That can mean extra cooking and extra grocery costs for the rest of the family.

Mom’s Request for Enough Sides

When she posted the sign-up sheet, her mom replied that they needed to make sure there were enough sides this year. That set the tone for the planning.

The woman asked if everyone was okay with her assigning dishes this time. Everyone agreed, including her brother.

That gave her permission to fill in the sheet herself. She wanted the meal to come together without last-minute surprises.

Assigning Every Dish

She went through the list and assigned something to every person. She tried to make sure each part of the meal was covered.

Side dishes can be some of the most expensive and time-consuming parts of Thanksgiving. Depending on the recipe, a single dish can cost $15 to $30 or more.

By assigning dishes ahead of time, she hoped the family would end up with a complete meal. She wanted to avoid repeats of past years.

Ice and Paper Plates

Next to her brother’s name, she wrote “ice and paper plates.” That was his only assignment.

She knew everyone in the family would understand why she chose ice. It was a nod to the last few years.

It also meant he’d be bringing something inexpensive and easy. Ice and paper plates typically cost only a few dollars.

His Girlfriend’s First Thanksgiving

This year, her brother’s girlfriend is joining them for Thanksgiving for the first time. She wanted to bring a dessert.

The woman asked her brother to send the sign-up link so his girlfriend could add her name. She signed up to bring brownies, right below his assignment.

His girlfriend asked him why he was assigned ice. He told her it was a family joke and that he was actually making the stuffing.

Family Joke and a Promise of Stuffing

Her brother called and asked her to change the sheet. He wanted her to tell everyone to stop joking about the ice.

He doesn’t usually cook and often works double shifts around the holidays. He’s also the one who washes all the dishes after dinner while everyone else relaxes.

Her mom thinks she should just change it because it’s Thanksgiving. Her sister says he brought it on himself.

Rewriting the Sheet or Leaving It Alone

She knew his girlfriend might see the sign-up sheet when she assigned ice. She also knows she could have talked to him privately instead.

At the same time, she gave him the assignment because he’s brought ice for years, and her mom wanted more sides this time. She’s left deciding whether to rewrite the sheet to support his story or leave it as it is, knowing either choice could make Thanksgiving a little more awkward.

Featured on Happy From Home:

Similar Posts