Woman and mother arguing on couch

She’s Tired of Explaining the Same Rules to Her Mother-in-Law Over and Over, but Her Mother-in-Law Wants Future Concerns Handled Privately, and Now She Doesn’t Know Whether to Change How She Speaks Up

A mom has a firm rule for her kids, nobody has to hug anyone they don’t want to. So when her mother-in-law repeatedly told her oldest child she wouldn’t get a gift unless she gave Grandma a hug, the mom spoke up loudly enough for everyone to hear.

It wasn’t the first time she’s had to correct her mother-in-law in front of family. Now her mother-in-law says she feels humiliated and wants future concerns handled privately, and the mom is wondering whether to change her approach.

Visits From Her In-Laws

Her in-laws recently came over to see the family. Like many grandparents, they were especially excited to spend time with the kids.

Visits like that are often filled with hugs, games, and small gifts. Grandparents usually look forward to those moments.

But one part of these visits has become a recurring issue. It involves her oldest child and her mother-in-law.

Hugs Grandpa Gets but Grandma Doesn’t

Her oldest child happily hugs her father-in-law when he asks. With her mother-in-law, though, the child often says no.

Some children feel more comfortable with certain relatives than others. Many parents believe kids should be allowed to choose when they want physical affection.

The mom respects her child’s choice. She doesn’t want her kids to feel pressured into hugging anyone.

Gifts Used as Bribes

On more than one occasion, her mother-in-law brought gifts. When the child refused a hug, her mother-in-law said she guessed she wouldn’t give the present after all.

To the mom, that felt like using a gift to pressure her child. She didn’t want her daughter learning that affection is something owed in exchange for presents.

Each time, she said out loud that her child didn’t have to hug anyone she didn’t want to. Her husband, his father, and other relatives were in the room both times.

Rules About Sugar Before Age 2

There’s a longer history behind the tension. The couple follows their pediatrician’s advice to limit sugary foods until their kids turn 2.

They’ve allowed some foods with small amounts of sugar, like peanut butter. But they’ve avoided desserts and very sugary drinks.

Her mother-in-law has repeatedly tried to give the kids treats and sugary drinks anyway. Each time, the parents explained their rule.

Acting Like She’d Never Heard It Before

Every time they say no, her mother-in-law acts surprised. She suggests it isn’t a big deal and that they’re being too strict.

The mom feels like she has to explain the same rule over and over. Her mother-in-law often reacts as if she’s hearing it for the first time.

That repetition has worn on her patience. It makes it harder to trust that her rules will be respected.

Blue Icing at a Family Gathering

Over the summer, at a large family gathering, the mom noticed her 1-year-old’s mouth was bright blue. It matched the icing on the cake.

She asked her mother-in-law if she’d given the baby icing. Her mother-in-law admitted she had and said she didn’t ask first because she knew the answer would be no.

The mom was furious. She told her mother-in-law loudly that it was disrespectful, then left the room.

Call About Feeling Humiliated

A few days after the most recent hug situation, her mother-in-law called. She sounded upset and said she felt humiliated.

She said she respects the couple’s parenting rules. But she asked that, in the future, the mom pull her aside privately instead of correcting her in front of others.

The mom understands why her mother-in-law felt embarrassed. Still, she isn’t sure a private conversation would change anything.

Speaking Up in Front of Family

She’s wondering whether she was wrong to address the issues publicly. She also isn’t sure whether she should keep doing it.

To her, speaking up in the moment protects her kids and makes her boundaries clear. She’s left trying to decide whether a quieter approach might ease family tension, or whether her mother-in-law’s history means public reminders are the only ones that work.

Featured on Happy From Home:

Similar Posts