Neighbors seemingly arguing across a fence

His New Neighbor Who Plans to Rent Out Her House Wants His 20-Year-Old Oak Tree Cut Down Because Leaves Fall in Her Pool, and She Told Him She’s a Lawyer and Doesn’t Want Things to Get Messy

A man has lived in his home for more than 20 years, and a healthy, mature oak tree stands in his backyard. Its branches stretch over the fence into the yard next door, where a new neighbor moved in just a month ago.

The neighbor, who plans to rent the house out as an investment, wants the oak cut down because its leaves fall into her pool. When he said he wanted to consult his own arborist first, she mentioned she’s a lawyer and said she didn’t want things to get messy.

Twenty Years With a Mature Oak

He and his wife have lived in their home for more than two decades. Over that time, the oak tree has become one of the most valued parts of their property.

Mature trees can add real value to a home. They provide shade, privacy, and curb appeal that newer landscaping often can’t match.

In their neighborhood, not many homes still have large, established trees. That makes the oak even more special to them.

Shade Through Hot Summers

Where they live, summers get very hot. The tree’s shade helps keep their yard and home cooler.

Shade from mature trees can help reduce cooling costs. In some homes, that can lower summer energy bills by a noticeable amount.

For them, the tree isn’t just about looks. It plays a practical role in making their property more comfortable.

New Neighbor’s Request

A new neighbor moved in next door about a month ago. They had never spoken to her before.

She got his wife’s phone number from her real estate agent, who is also her son. Then she asked if they’d be open to talking about cutting down the tree.

The tree is in their yard, but some branches extend over the fence. The neighbor says leaves are falling into her pool.

Leaves in the Pool

He understands leaves can be frustrating for pool owners. Cleaning debris out of a pool takes time and can add maintenance costs.

Still, past neighbors never asked for the tree to be removed. He’s had four neighbors next door since buying the house.

They all told him the shade was worth the leaves. None of them ever suggested cutting it down.

Concern About Trimming Too Much

He’s worried that trimming the branches over the fence could seriously harm the tree. Removing too much at once can stress a tree and eventually kill it.

He and his wife recently removed other trees and updated their landscaping. Their longtime arborist advised waiting before making more major changes.

That arborist hasn’t inspected the oak yet. Until he does, they don’t know how much trimming the tree could safely handle.

Talk of Getting Messy

His wife told the neighbor they weren’t interested in removing the tree. Soon after, the neighbor came to their front door to discuss it in person.

He told her they were open to talking but needed to consult their arborist first. She mentioned she was a lawyer and said she didn’t want things to get messy.

That comment worried him. He started wondering what rights she has and whether trimming her side could legally put the tree at risk.

Investment Property and More Trees

The neighbor said she doesn’t plan to live in the house. She sees it as an investment and plans to rent it out.

She also wants two more trees on their property removed, even though they aren’t near her home. She offered to have her own arborist cut down the oak and trim what she called the ugly trees.

She doesn’t want them using their own arborist. Removing large trees can easily cost hundreds or even thousands of dollars each, and he feels decisions about his property should be made with someone he trusts.

Protecting the Tree and Keeping the Peace

He’s cut down trees before, but he’s never felt this protective of one. The oak feels like part of his home.

He’s also thinking about the future. He’ll have to live next to whoever owns or rents that house for years to come, and he’s left wondering how to protect his tree without turning a new neighbor into a long-term legal headache.

Featured on Happy From Home:

Similar Posts